Propane vs Gas Generator for RV: Which One Should You Choose?

When it comes to RV living, having a reliable power source is essential. Whether you’re taking a short weekend trip to a campground or embarking on an off-grid adventure, the right generator can make all the difference in keeping your appliances running and your RV comfortable. Among the most popular choices are propane and gas generators, each offering distinct advantages and trade-offs.

In this guide, we’ll explore the key differences between propane and gas generators, comparing them in terms of efficiency, cost, environmental impact, and other important factors. We’ll also provide situational recommendations to help you determine the best choice for your RV lifestyle. By the end, you’ll have all the information you need to make an informed decision and power your next adventure with confidence.

Understanding the Basics

What is a Propane Generator?

A propane generator is a power generation device that uses liquid propane gas (LPG) as its primary fuel source. Propane is stored in pressurized tanks, either in smaller portable cylinders or larger tanks typically found on RVs. When the generator operates, propane is converted into a gaseous state, mixed with air, and ignited to produce energy. This energy powers the generator’s motor, which in turn generates electricity.

How It Works?

Propane generators use an internal combustion engine that operates similarly to gasoline-powered engines. The difference lies in the fuel delivery system. Propane, as a clean-burning fuel, creates combustion that drives the generator’s motor. The process starts with the propane tank supplying gas to the generator through a fuel line. Once the fuel reaches the carburetor, it is combined with air, compressed, and ignited in the combustion chamber. This drives the motor and produces mechanical energy, which is converted into electricity.

Key Features and Benefits

• Clean-Burning Fuel: Propane burns more cleanly compared to gasoline, resulting in fewer emissions and a reduced environmental impact.
• Long Shelf Life: Propane can be stored indefinitely without degradation, making it an excellent choice for long-term RV trips or as a backup power source.
• Quieter Operation: Many propane generators are quieter than their gas counterparts, making them ideal for campsites or situations where noise restrictions apply.
• Cold Weather Performance: Propane performs better in cold temperatures compared to gasoline, which can gel or degrade in low temperatures.
• Convenience for RVs: Many RVs already have built-in propane tanks, making it easy to integrate a propane generator without needing a separate fuel source.

What is a Gas Generator?

A gas generator is a device powered by traditional gasoline to produce electricity. Gasoline is one of the most common and widely available fuels, making gas generators a popular choice for RV owners. These generators are known for their versatility, as they can provide significant power output and are easy to refuel almost anywhere.

How It Works?

Gas generators operate using a four-stroke or two-stroke internal combustion engine. The generator’s fuel tank stores gasoline, which is fed into the engine. Once inside, gasoline is mixed with air and ignited by a spark plug in the combustion chamber. This ignition creates a series of small explosions, driving the engine’s pistons. The pistons’ movement powers the generator’s motor, converting mechanical energy into electrical energy that powers your RV.

Key Features and Benefits

• High Power Output: Gas generators are generally capable of producing higher power output compared to propane generators of the same size, making them suitable for energy-intensive appliances.
• Widespread Fuel Availability: Gasoline can be found almost anywhere, from gas stations to convenience stores, making it a convenient choice for long-distance RV travelers.
• Cost-Effective for Short-Term Use: Gas generators are often more affordable upfront, and gasoline can sometimes be cheaper than propane depending on location.
• Ease of Refueling: Unlike propane, which requires swapping tanks or refilling from specialized stations, gas generators can be refueled quickly with a standard gas can.
• Compatibility with Accessories: Many gas generators come with additional features such as built-in inverters, electric start options, and advanced controls, making them adaptable for RV users’ needs.

Comparison: Propane vs Gas Generator

Efficiency and Fuel Availability

How Efficient Are Propane and Gas Generators?
Propane generators are generally less efficient than gas generators when it comes to power output. This is because propane contains fewer BTUs (British Thermal Units) per gallon compared to gasoline. As a result, propane generators burn more fuel to produce the same amount of energy as a gas generator. However, the difference in efficiency may not always be a dealbreaker, especially for RV owners who prioritize convenience or cleaner fuel options. Gas generators, on the other hand, are more fuel-efficient and can deliver higher power output for energy-demanding appliances, making them ideal for heavy-duty use.

Availability of Propane vs Gasoline When Traveling
Gasoline is widely available at virtually every gas station, making it easy to refuel a gas generator no matter where you’re traveling. Propane, while also commonly found, may not be as readily available in remote or rural areas. RV travelers using propane generators often need to plan ahead and locate refill stations or bring spare propane tanks. However, if your RV already has a built-in propane system, access to fuel may not be as much of an issue. Ultimately, gasoline’s widespread availability gives gas generators a slight advantage for longer road trips with less planning.

Cost

Initial Purchase Cost
Gas generators are typically less expensive to purchase than propane generators. This is because gasoline-powered engines are more common, and manufacturers often produce gas generators in greater quantities, which lowers the cost. Propane generators, being less common and requiring additional fuel system components, tend to have a higher upfront price.

Ongoing Fuel Costs
The cost of operating a generator depends on fuel prices, which can vary significantly depending on location and market conditions. Gasoline is often less expensive per gallon compared to propane, but it also burns faster, which can offset the cost advantage. Propane, while more expensive upfront, is generally more stable in price and burns cleaner, reducing wear and tear on the engine, which could save money on maintenance in the long run. For frequent RV users, propane may prove to be more cost-effective over time despite its higher initial cost.

Environmental Impact

Emissions and Pollution: Propane vs Gasoline
Propane is a much cleaner-burning fuel compared to gasoline. It produces fewer harmful emissions such as carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and particulate matter. This makes propane a more eco-friendly choice, particularly for RV enthusiasts who value sustainability and reducing their carbon footprint. Gasoline, while efficient, emits more greenhouse gases and pollutants, contributing to environmental degradation.

Eco-Friendliness for RV Enthusiasts
For RV owners who enjoy camping in national parks or pristine natural areas, propane generators align better with eco-conscious living. Many RV parks also have restrictions on generator emissions, giving propane an advantage in compliance. While gas generators remain popular for their efficiency, their environmental impact is a factor that cannot be ignored.

Maintenance and Durability

Maintenance Requirements for Each Type
Propane generators require less maintenance compared to gas generators. Propane burns cleaner, leaving fewer carbon deposits in the engine, which means less frequent cleaning and fewer oil changes. Gasoline, in contrast, can leave behind residue and varnish in the fuel system, requiring regular maintenance to keep the engine running smoothly. Additionally, gasoline is more prone to degradation, which can clog fuel lines and carburetors if not used quickly or stored properly.

Longevity and Reliability
Propane generators often have a longer lifespan because the cleaner-burning fuel causes less wear and tear on the engine components. Gas generators, while powerful and efficient, may require more frequent repairs and maintenance over time. However, both types of generators are reliable if properly cared for, and the choice ultimately depends on how much maintenance you’re willing to handle.

Noise Levels

Quietness of Propane vs Gas Generators
Propane generators are generally quieter than gas generators. This is partly due to the smoother combustion process of propane and the fact that propane engines are often designed with noise reduction in mind. For RV users who value peace and quiet while camping, propane generators are the better option. Gas generators, while not excessively loud, tend to produce more noise, especially under heavy loads.

Why Noise Levels Matter for RV Living
Noise levels are an important consideration for RV living, particularly in campgrounds or boondocking areas where other campers are nearby. A noisy generator can disrupt the serenity of your surroundings and may even be subject to restrictions in some locations. Choosing a quieter option like a propane generator can enhance your camping experience and reduce the likelihood of complaints from fellow campers.

Pros and Cons of Each Generator

Propane Generator: Pros and Cons

Pros: Cleaner Fuel
Propane is a clean-burning fuel that produces fewer emissions compared to gasoline. It generates significantly lower levels of carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and other harmful pollutants. This makes propane generators a more environmentally friendly choice for RV owners who care about sustainability and reducing their carbon footprint. Additionally, propane combustion leaves fewer residues in the engine, which contributes to less wear and tear and longer engine life.

Pros: Longer Storage Life
Propane has an indefinite shelf life, meaning it doesn’t degrade over time like gasoline does. This makes it an excellent option for RVers who need a reliable backup power source. Whether you’re taking occasional trips or storing your RV for long periods, you won’t need to worry about propane going bad. In contrast, gasoline can start to break down within months, requiring additives or replacement to remain effective.

Pros: Quieter Operation
Propane generators are typically quieter than their gas-powered counterparts. This is due to the smoother combustion process of propane, which results in less mechanical noise. For RV owners who camp in serene, natural settings or share campgrounds with others, a quieter generator enhances the experience and reduces disturbances to others. Many propane generators are designed specifically to meet noise level restrictions in campgrounds.

Cons: Less Efficient
One downside of propane generators is that they are less efficient than gas generators. Propane contains fewer BTUs (British Thermal Units) per gallon compared to gasoline, which means it takes more propane to produce the same amount of power. For RV owners with high energy demands, this inefficiency can result in more frequent refueling and higher operational costs.

Cons: Harder to Find Propane in Remote Areas
While propane is widely available, it’s not as universally accessible as gasoline. In remote areas or along less-traveled routes, finding propane refill stations can be a challenge. This may require additional planning or carrying extra propane tanks, which can take up valuable storage space in your RV. If you plan on traveling to very isolated areas, the limited availability of propane could be a significant drawback.

Gas Generator: Pros and Cons

Pros: Widely Available Fuel
One of the biggest advantages of gas generators is the widespread availability of gasoline. Virtually every gas station carries it, making it easy to refuel your generator no matter where you’re traveling. For RVers who value convenience and flexibility, the ubiquity of gasoline is a major benefit. You won’t need to plan ahead as much or worry about running out of fuel in unfamiliar areas.

Pros: Higher Power Output
Gas generators are typically more powerful and efficient than propane generators. They can produce higher wattage output, making them better suited for RV owners who need to run energy-intensive appliances like air conditioners, microwaves, or refrigerators. This makes gasoline generators an ideal choice for large RVs or those who need reliable power for extended periods.

Cons: Noisier Operation
Gasoline generators are often noisier than propane generators. The combustion process in gas engines tends to produce more mechanical noise, especially under heavy loads. For RVers who value peace and quiet or camp in noise-restricted areas, this can be a significant drawback. Excessive noise may also disturb fellow campers, reducing the overall enjoyment of your trip.

Cons: Shorter Shelf Life for Fuel
Gasoline has a relatively short shelf life compared to propane. It can degrade in as little as three to six months if not properly stored, especially if it’s exposed to heat, air, or moisture. This requires careful management, including the use of fuel stabilizers or regular cycling of stored fuel. For RV owners who don’t use their generator frequently, this can be inconvenient and lead to wasted fuel.

Cons: Higher Emissions
Gasoline generators produce higher levels of harmful emissions compared to propane. They emit more carbon monoxide and other pollutants, which can be hazardous if not properly vented. For environmentally conscious RVers or those camping in pristine natural settings, the higher emissions of gas generators may be a dealbreaker. Additionally, some campgrounds or RV parks may have restrictions on the use of high-emission generators.

Situational Recommendations

Best Choice for Short-Term RV Trips

For short-term RV trips, a gas generator is often the better option. The convenience of gasoline’s widespread availability makes it easy to refuel on the go, without needing to plan ahead or locate propane refill stations. Gasoline generators also provide higher power output, which is useful if you need to run multiple appliances or power-heavy equipment for brief periods.

Additionally, gas generators tend to have a lower initial cost, making them a more budget-friendly choice for RVers who only take occasional trips. Since short-term trips typically involve limited generator usage, the maintenance and emissions concerns associated with gas generators are less likely to be significant issues. Overall, the combination of accessibility, affordability, and power makes gas generators an excellent choice for weekend getaways or short vacations.

Best Choice for Off-Grid or Boondocking RV Living

For off-grid or boondocking RV living, a propane generator is the superior option. The cleaner-burning fuel ensures fewer emissions, which is particularly important when camping in pristine natural environments. Propane’s longer shelf life also makes it ideal for off-grid living, as you won’t have to worry about fuel degradation over extended periods. This reliability is a major advantage for those spending weeks or months away from standard fuel stations.

Propane generators are also quieter, which is important when camping off-grid in serene, noise-sensitive areas. Additionally, many RVs already have built-in propane tanks for heating and cooking, making it easier to integrate a propane generator into your power system without the need for additional fuel storage.

However, propane availability should be considered when boondocking in remote areas. If you’re traveling far from major highways or cities, it’s essential to plan ahead and bring enough propane or know the location of refill stations. Despite this limitation, propane generators are the best choice for those who prioritize sustainability, reliability, and a low-maintenance power source in off-grid conditions.

Seasonal Considerations (Cold Weather, High Altitudes)

Cold Weather: In cold weather, propane generators have a distinct advantage over gas generators. Gasoline can become less effective in freezing temperatures, as it is prone to gelling or degrading when exposed to extreme cold. Propane, on the other hand, remains stable and functional in low temperatures, making it more reliable for RVers traveling in winter climates. Additionally, propane’s clean-burning properties mean less strain on the engine, reducing the likelihood of starting issues in cold conditions.

High Altitudes: At high altitudes, propane generators also tend to perform better than gas generators. Gasoline engines rely on a precise fuel-to-air mixture for combustion, and the thinner air at higher elevations can disrupt this balance, leading to decreased efficiency and power output. While propane generators are not immune to altitude-related issues, they are less affected because propane is already in a gaseous state, making combustion more consistent. For RVers traveling through mountainous regions, a propane generator is generally the more reliable choice.

In contrast, gas generators may struggle in both cold weather and high-altitude environments, requiring adjustments or additional maintenance to function effectively. While gasoline generators remain viable in moderate climates and elevations, propane’s stability and adaptability make it the better option for extreme weather conditions or challenging terrains.

Enjoyed this guide of Propane vs Gas Generator for RV: Which One Should You Choose? Then be sured to check out our other RV guides.

• Best 12 Volt RV Battery
• Best Cell Phone Signal Booster for RV
• Best Generator for 30 Amp RV
• Best Generator for 50 Amp RV
• Best 3000 Watt Inverter Generator for RV
• Best Dual Fuel Inverter Generator for RV